The hearing's over, but people still aren't buying Kavanaugh's discredited argument

Days later social media still rages with talk of Kavanaugh's dishonesty.
By Nicole Gallucci  on 
The hearing's over, but people still aren't buying Kavanaugh's discredited argument
Brett Kavanaugh at his Senate Judiciary Committee hearing. Credit: ERIN SCHAFF/POOL/EPA-EFE/REX/Shutterstock

Brett Kavanaugh's seemingly tenuous relationship with the truth is still haunting those who watched him testify on Thursday.

At times, the prospective Supreme Court justice abandoned composure to shed tears and scream, but at his most jarring he straight-up refused to answer questions directly, was unwilling to request an FBI investigation, and, as further research revealed, apparently lied under oath.

In the days since the hearing, people have replayed his testimony in their minds and on their screens. They've turned Kavanaugh's words around over and over again to really let them simmer. And it seems the more thought that's given to his responses, the more discussions about his dishonesty rage on social media.

One of the major, most general causes of concern about Kavanaugh's testimony is the simple fact that a federal judge, who quite literally navigates the law for a living, refused to answer so many key questions.

Following the hearing and testimonies of both Kavanaugh and Christine Blasey Ford — who accused Kavanaugh of sexual assault in an incident that occurred more than 30 years ago, when the two were in high school — Vox created a visually striking chart to compare the times Ford and Kavanaugh each answered or dodged a question.

Ford's portion is covered in blue, which signifies she did her best to answer each question presented to her in her testimony, while Kavanaugh's chart is sprinkled with pink lines, a representation of the numerous times he dodged questions.

When Kavanaugh did make an effort to answer basic questions, like those pertaining to his controversial senior yearbook writeup and personal calendar, it wasn't satisfactory. Again and again he wholeheartedly failed to provide accurate explanations and definitions for terms like "Devil’s Triangle," "boof," "ralph," and more — terms that any person with access to the internet could look up for themselves and fact check. And you'd better believe they did.

Kavanaugh also stated that 18-year-olds could legally drink in Maryland in 1982, which was true if you turned 18 before July 1. However, a simple search reveals Kavanaugh didn't turn 18 until Feb. 12, 1983 which means he wasn't legally allowed to drink until age 21 in Maryland. C'mon, dude.

And then, of course, beyond questions surrounding whether it was legal for him to drink at all, there's his deep, deep love of beer itself.

Kavanaugh sounded like a broken record throughout his testimony, passionately declaring his love for beer whenever the opportunity presented itself. Yet, at the same time, the man giving beer such rave reviews also wanted the world to believe the following:

  • He never drank on weekdays, despite his beloved teenage calendar — an argued symbol of absolute truth — implying otherwise.

  • He never drank in excess to the point of blacking out, despite saying "sometimes I had too many beers," in his opening statement; embarrassingly refusing to answer a question about drinking in excess; and that questionable section from his pal Mark Judge’s memoir, Wasted: Tales of a GenX Drunk, that describes a character Bart O’Kavanaugh "vomiting on someone’s car during Beach Week and then passing out."

  • He has a "weak stomach with beer or with spicy food or anything."

With all the conflicting beer-related information presented that day, it's no wonder people are still left with some serious questions and concerns. Some are even gathering evidence from trustworthy sources to create Twitter threads that prove Kavanaugh was far more than a light drinker in the past.

One of the most widely called out points Kavanaugh used to strengthen his own argument was that the possible witnesses Ford mentioned in her testimony — including Mark Judge, Patrick "P.J." Smyth, Leland Ingraham Keyser, and another unnamed boy — all denied the sexual assault ever took place.

Kavanaugh leaned on the argument several times on Thursday, prompting many -- including Senator Richard Blumenthal -- to note that the claim was completely inaccurate. Blumenthal even took the time to publicly state that a person having "no recollection" of the event or not knowing the answer to a question is not the same as denying the event took place.

On Friday, after pleas from Democratic senators and support from outside parties like the American Bar Association and Dean of Yale Law School, Kavanaugh's Senate confirmation vote was delayed to accommodate a requested week-long FBI investigation.

President Trump granted a short investigation that will remain limited in scope, and while it's unclear exactly how the FBI will approach Ford's accusations or examine the claims of other Kavanaugh accusers Julie Swetnick and Deborah Ramirez, here's hoping the country gains some additional sense of clarity on Ford's accusations and Kavanaugh's high school years beyond the vague, often confusing statements he made to the Senate Judiciary Committee.

Mashable Image
Nicole Gallucci

Nicole is a Senior Editor at Mashable. She primarily covers entertainment and digital culture trends, and in her free time she can be found watching TV, sending voice notes, or going viral on Twitter for admiring knitwear. You can follow her on Twitter @nicolemichele5.


Recommended For You
Ayo Edebiri's Instagram Story with Paul Mescal stokes rom-com rumors
Andrew Scott, Ayo Edebiri, and Paul Mescal posing for a photo at the BAFTAs.

'Mama, kudos for saying that' is the internet's new favorite reaction
RuPaul and drag queens posing at the Emmy's.

Why the internet stans Ireland
Barry Keoghan, Saoirse Ronan, Cillian Murphy, Colin Farrell, and Ayo Edebiri.

Black Mirror season 7 is coming — 5 things the internet is saying about its return
Black Mirror splash screen on Netflix


More in Life
How to watch Virginia vs. Colorado State basketball without cable
Isaac McKneely #11 of the Virginia Cavaliers men’s basketball team shoots between Elliot Cadeau #2 and Cormac Ryan #3 of the North Carolina Tar Heels in the second half during a game at John Paul Jones Arena on February 24, 2024, in Charlottesville, Virginia.

How to watch Howard vs. Wagner basketball without cable
Head coach Kenny Blakeney of the Howard Bison looks on during the first half in the first round of the NCAA Men's Basketball Tournament at Wells Fargo Arena on March 16, 2023, in Des Moines, Iowa.

How to watch Atlético Madrid vs. Barcelona online for free
Players of FC Barcelona celebrating their team's first goal

How to watch Manchester United vs. Liverpool online for free
Kobbie Mainoo of Manchester United

How to watch Denver Nuggets vs. Dallas Mavericks online for free
Luka Doncic of the Dallas Mavericks goes to the basket

Trending on Mashable
NYT Connections today: See hints and answers for March 19
A phone displaying the New York Times game 'Connections.'

Wordle today: Here's the answer and hints for March 19
a phone displaying Wordle

NASA scientist viewed first Voyager images. What he saw gave him chills.
Both Voyager spacecraft have entered interstellar space, billions of miles beyond Earth.

Watch the Elon Musk interview that probably ended Don Lemon's partnership with Twitter/X
A composite of Don Lemon and Elon Musk on "The Don Lemon Show."

NYT Connections today: See hints and answers for March 18
A phone displaying the New York Times game 'Connections.'
The biggest stories of the day delivered to your inbox.
This newsletter may contain advertising, deals, or affiliate links. Subscribing to a newsletter indicates your consent to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe from the newsletters at any time.
Thanks for signing up. See you at your inbox!